Land and Environment Court

Caught out on the stairs: Court overturns refusal decided on an issue no one raised

A Mosman homeowner's plan for a rooftop terrace was refused because of overlooking from the external stairs to the terrace. But the council's case had been about the terrace itself, and no one had raised the stairs. The Land and Environment Court has set the refusal aside for denial of procedural fairness.

We explain why a Commissioner must give a party notice before deciding a case on an issue that neither side has argued.

Lodged on time, still lapsed: the deferred commencement trap

A Bellevue Hill homeowner lodged the plans needed to activate a deferred commencement consent two weeks before the deadline. Because the council did not finish assessing them until after the deadline, the Land and Environment Court held that the consent had lapsed.

We explain why lodging on time was not enough, and what holders of deferred commencement consents should do to avoid the same result.

Tourist accommodation, but still prohibited: Court rules on caravan park proposal

A proposed caravan park at Alstonville was found to be "tourist accommodation", even with many sites intended for long-term stays. However, the Court held that this did not override the zone's prohibition on caravan parks.

We explain why a clause regulating a type of development does not necessarily make it permissible.

Court upholds Housing Delivery Authority "State significant" declaration

The Land and Environment Court has dismissed a challenge to the Minister's decision to declare a North Sydney shop-top housing proposal State significant development through the Housing Delivery Authority pathway.

We explain how the pathway works, why the challenge failed and what it means for proponents and objectors.

Assess the application in front of you: amended DA must be the one considered

A digital sign on the former Grace Bros building in Ultimo was refused after the Commissioner assessed a superseded visual impact report rather than the new one filed with the amended application. The Chief Judge set the decision aside.

We explain why the amended application must be the one assessed, and what this means when applications change during an appeal.

Are “dwelling entitlements” a relic of the past?

In Wilson v Kiama Municipal Council [2026] NSWLEC 1423, our firm acted for the successful applicant seeking development consent for a dwelling on an undersized rural lot on which there was no “dwelling entitlement”.

This case confirms that, while the term “dwelling entitlement” is often used by Councils, planners and developers, it is not a phrase that is used in the modern Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 or any environmental planning instruments made under it.

The real question is whether the provision is a “development standard” or a “prohibition”. If it is a development standard that is amenable to cl 4.6, it is open to the consent authority to grant consent provided the requirements of cl 4.6 are met.

The absence of a “dwelling entitlement” is irrelevant and does not prevent the grant of consent.

A dividing fence is still development: Court orders boundary wall demolished

Homeowners who built a masonry boundary wall, planter boxes and a screen argued they did not need development consent because the wall was a dividing fence. The Land and Environment Court disagreed and ordered the unapproved parts demolished.

We explain why the Dividing Fences Act does not replace planning approval, and why a neighbour's heritage listing can rule out exempt development.

Heritage listing blocks fast-track approval for a telco facility

A private certifier approved a rooftop mobile phone facility on a heritage-listed building in Collaroy as complying development. The Land and Environment Court declared the certificate invalid, because development on a heritage item cannot be complying development.

We explain how the two State planning policies interact and what this means for infrastructure and other fast-track approvals.

A mortgagee's claim isn't capped by the owner's silence: compensation for flood-prone land

When land is compulsorily acquired, a mortgagee can pursue its own compensation claim even if the landowner has been deemed to accept the offer by not responding. That is the first ruling of its kind from the Land and Environment Court.

We also look at the Court's findings on valuing flood-prone land.

Giant trees, a $450,000 penalty and restorative justice: Forestry Corporation sentenced

Forestry Corporation of NSW has been ordered to pay $450,000 after pleading guilty to cutting down six giant trees and three hollow-bearing trees that were required to be protected in Wild Cattle Creek State Forest.

We look at how the Court weighed environmental harm, cultural harm to the local First Nations community and a restorative justice process in sentencing.

Strata renewal plan approved over objections: what counts as a "relationship" with the developer?

The Land and Environment Court has approved a strata renewal plan to redevelop three 1960s apartment buildings in Cronulla, requiring three dissenting owners to sell.

We explain the statutory tests and why a casual business acquaintance between the strata committee and the developer was not a disqualifying "relationship".

Wrong company on the DA? Court allows the applicant to be swapped

A development application was lodged in the wrong company's name, and that company later went into liquidation during the appeal. The Land and Environment Court allowed the correct company to be substituted.

We explain the steps taken to fix the mistake, and why the order in which they are taken matters.

Boarding house conversions: viability must be assessed for the building as it is

A Commissioner refused to allow a Paddington boarding house to be converted into terraces, reasoning that an upgraded boarding house could be viable. The Chief Judge held that the Housing SEPP requires the viability of the existing boarding house to be assessed.

We explain what the decision means for conversions of low-rental buildings.

Community facility or place of worship? Court approves shared-use proposal in Minto

Can part of a family home be used as a community facility run by a religious charity, without it being a prohibited "place of public worship"? The Land and Environment Court said yes, approving a shared-use proposal in Minto.

Our firm acted for the successful applicant. We explain how the Court approached characterisation and shared spaces.

Deed lodged, condition satisfied: when a deferred commencement consent doesn't need council sign-off

A Gosford developer lodged a signed deed with the council to satisfy a deferred commencement condition. Years later, the council said the deed was inadequate and the consent had lapsed. The Land and Environment Court disagreed and declared that the condition had been satisfied.

We explain why the wording of the condition was decisive.

Neighbour overturns duplex modification over overlooked DCP controls

A self-represented neighbour has successfully challenged Randwick Council's approval of a modification to a Matraville duplex that cut the rear setback by about 30 per cent. The Court found that the Council failed to consider two relevant DCP controls.

We explain why modification applications need the same attention to planning controls as development applications.

Third time unlucky: Court stops neighbours re-litigating a tree dispute

After losing two tree dispute cases about the same trees, neighbours brought a third. The Land and Environment Court dismissed it and made a vexatious proceedings order preventing them from suing our client in the Court for two years without leave.

Our firm acted for the successful respondent. We explain the principles of finality and the vexatious proceedings regime.