EP&A Act

The 98 per cent problem: High Court finds coal mine approval invalid over scope 3 emissions

In a 3:2 decision, the High Court has upheld a community group's challenge to the approval of the Mount Pleasant coal mine expansion in the Upper Hunter. The majority found that the Independent Planning Commission failed to consider whether to impose conditions to minimise the project's scope 3 emissions, which make up 98 per cent of its total emissions.

All five justices rejected the Court of Appeal's view that the EPA Act is centrally concerned with impacts "in the locality". We explain both findings and what they mean for resource projects and consent authorities.

Old consents, new disputes: Court of Appeal on reading consents and drafting injunctions

The Court of Appeal has confirmed that old development consents are read according to their terms and approved plans, finding that a Picton landowner had used his property well beyond what three consents allowed.

The Court also set aside injunctions that were drafted too broadly. We explain both lessons for landowners and councils.

Court upholds Housing Delivery Authority "State significant" declaration

The Land and Environment Court has dismissed a challenge to the Minister's decision to declare a North Sydney shop-top housing proposal State significant development through the Housing Delivery Authority pathway.

We explain how the pathway works, why the challenge failed and what it means for proponents and objectors.

All or nothing? The risk of bundling changes into one modification application

A homeowner's modification application included some changes the Commissioner found acceptable and others the council did not even oppose, but the whole application was refused. The Court of Appeal held that there was no duty to approve it in part.

We look at why bundling changes into one modification application can be risky, and how to manage that risk.

Are “dwelling entitlements” a relic of the past?

In Wilson v Kiama Municipal Council [2026] NSWLEC 1423, our firm acted for the successful applicant seeking development consent for a dwelling on an undersized rural lot on which there was no “dwelling entitlement”.

This case confirms that, while the term “dwelling entitlement” is often used by Councils, planners and developers, it is not a phrase that is used in the modern Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 or any environmental planning instruments made under it.

The real question is whether the provision is a “development standard” or a “prohibition”. If it is a development standard that is amenable to cl 4.6, it is open to the consent authority to grant consent provided the requirements of cl 4.6 are met.

The absence of a “dwelling entitlement” is irrelevant and does not prevent the grant of consent.

Last orders? Losing a historic pub use can count against a change of use

An attempt to convert Paddington's heritage-listed Village Inn Hotel into a shop has failed. The Court accepted that the pub use was part of the building's heritage significance, and the owner's evidence that the pub was unviable fell short.

We explain the lessons for owners of heritage-listed buildings whose use is part of their significance.

No power, no payment: affordable housing contribution condition struck out

What has happened?

In Hanave Pty Ltd v Waverley Council [2025] NSWLEC 19, the Land and Environment Court declared invalid a condition requiring a developer in Bondi to pay an affordable housing contribution. The Court held that the condition could be severed, so the rest of the development consent remained in force.

Context

The Waverley Local Planning Panel granted consent for development affecting a building used for affordable rental housing. The consent included a condition (condition 10) requiring a monetary contribution to offset the loss of affordable housing.

Under ss 4.17(1)(h) and 7.32 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (EPA Act), a consent authority can only impose an affordable housing contribution condition if an environmental planning instrument authorises it. The Waverley LEP contained no such provision. The Council relied instead on a transitional clause (cl 15A) in the 2017 savings and transitional regulation.

The decision

Justice Pritchard held that:

  • cl 15A was validly made, but on its proper construction it operated only "until" the commencement of the relevant part of the Act. When the earlier amending legislation was repealed in March 2018, cl 15A had no further work to do;

  • without authorisation in the Waverley LEP, the Panel had no power to impose the condition, so it was invalid; and

  • the condition could be severed. Unlike conditions designed to mitigate impacts before construction, removing a monetary contribution did not change how the rest of the consent would operate. The consent remained for the same development.

The respondents were ordered to pay the developer's costs.

How will this affect you?

  • Affordable housing contribution conditions must be authorised by an environmental planning instrument, usually the LEP. Developers should check the source of power for any such condition.

  • Invalid monetary conditions may be severable, leaving the rest of the consent intact.

  • Strict time limits apply to challenges to development consents. Act promptly if a condition appears to lack a lawful basis.

Further information

For further information please contact Darren Bick, Director, on +61 416 167 556 or darren.bick@bicksteele.com.au.

Errors of law, but no win: Kings Hill concept plan appeal dismissed

A developer proved two errors of law in the refusal of its Kings Hill concept plan, but still lost the appeal. The refusal rested on several independent grounds, and the errors would not have changed the outcome.

We explain the materiality principle and what it means for appeals against complex refusals.

Deemed refusal of DAs: Expiry of special COVID-19 provisions

The appeal period for an actual or deemed refusal for an application for development consent has reverted from 12 months back to 6 months following the expiry, on 25 March 2022, of the “prescribed period” introduced by the COVID-19 Legislation Amendment (Emergency Measures—Miscellaneous) Act 2020 (COVID Act).

Case Update: Is a private road a "building"?

In November 2017, we reported on the decision in Louisiana Properties Pty Ltd v Hakea Holdings Pty Ltd; Hakea Holdings Pty Ltd v Louisiana Properties Pty Ltd (No 2) [2017] NSWLEC 147 (Louisiana Properties).

In that case, the NSW Land and Environment Court held that a private road forming part of the subject matter of those proceedings was a ‘building’ for the purposes of the environment.

On 24 October 2018, the NSW Court of Appeal overturned this finding. Its reasons for so doing are briefly summarised in this case note.

Political Donations: an important reminder about disclosure obligations when making planning applications or public submissions

There have been several recent decisions in the Land and Environment Court in which companies have been convicted for failing to disclose political donations and gifts when making relevant planning applications.

This article provides a brief overview of the key issues which need to be considered when determining whether particular political donations need to be disclosed.

EP&A Act - Substantial Amendments

On 1 March 2018, the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 was substantially amended in what has been described by the NSW Government as the "biggest overhaul to the Act in 40 years".

Along with numerous substantive changes, the Act has also been completely renumbered.

To support these changes, the NSW Department of Planning & Environment has produced two essential resources which should be reviewed by anyone wishing to understand the scope and import of the amendments to the Act:

  1. a Guide to the updated Act which highlights the key changes made to each Part of the Act; and
  2. a Sections Guide which lists frequently used sections of the pre-amendment Act alongside their new section numbers in the amended Act.

For further information on these amendments and thepotential implications for your development please contact Marcus Steele, Director, on (02) 8005-1411 or marcus.steele@steelelaw.com.au.

 

 

SEPP 55 - Application to Planning Proposals & Gateway Determinations

Moorebank Recyclers Pty Ltd v Tanlane Pty Ltd (No 2)  [2017] NSWLEC 186.

In this case, the NSW Land and Environment Court considered the application of Clause 6 of State Environmental Planning Policy No 55 - Remediation of Land (SEPP 55):

  1. to the preparation of a Planning Proposal; and
  2. to the making of a Gateway determination.

The Court found that the Clause 6 of SEPP 55 was not engaged (and so did not need to be complied with) in the making of either decision under challenge.

Is a private road a "building"?

Louisiana Properties Pty Ltd v Hakea Holdings Pty Ltd; Hakea Holdings Pty Ltd v Louisiana Properties Pty Ltd (No 2) [2017] NSWLEC 147.

In this case, the NSW Land and Environment Court considered whether a private road constitutes a "building" for the purposes of the EP&A Act the construction of which requires authorisation under a construction certificate.

Applying the 3 characteristics of "structures" identified by Preston CJ in Royal Motor Yacht Club (Broken Bay) Pty Ltd v Northern Beaches Council [2017] NSWLEC 56, the Court found that the road did constitute a "structure" (and therefore a "building").

Modification of Part 3A Concept Approval to exclude land - Excluded landowner's consent not required

Platform Project Services Pty Ltd v Minister for Planning [2017] NSWLEC 102    

The NSW Land and Environment Court has confirmed that, where it is proposed to modify a Part 3A project approval to exclude land, it is not necessary to obtain consent from the owner of the excluded land.